Building a team for a small business comes with many different parts. You need people for daily operations, marketing, finances, and many other areas to make your business run smoothly. With all the different positions a small business needs to fill, sometimes it can be hard to determine the best way to add to your team. Hiring a long-term employee helps build the business and its relationships, but sometimes outsourcing can make a business flourish longer in a shorter amount of time. So, outsourcing vs. hiring. Which is better for your small business?
Table of Contents
Outsourcing vs. Hiring, What is the Difference?
Outsourcing is when a business recruits the help of an outside party for a good or service. Outsourcing usually involves paying an outside party a set rate for a set number of hours each week or month to get a project done, or even paying a single rate for a finished project. On the other hand, hiring is when a business directly employs someone to help with the business for a long period of time. Outsourcing is different from hiring because outsourcing involves a third party that does not directly work for the business, but serves in a contractor role, like a hired employee does.
Pros of Outsourcing
Outsourcing is a great way to have others take tasks off your plate so that you can focus on running your business. Some tasks that outsourcing is great for are creating new graphics and content, redesigning a website, or helping with IT and payroll. Some benefits of outsourcing are:
- Cost effective
- Outsourcing can be more cost-effective than hiring because it avoids the hidden expenses of hiring an employee and spending more money on training. A study done by ISG in 2024 shows that businesses save an average of 15% when using business process outsourcing compared to hiring in-house.
- Flexible
- Outsourcing is a flexible way to support a small business because it can be tailored entirely to the needs of a growing business. Outsourcing gives a business access to an already existing pool of talent that is ready to provide its talents and services to a business whenever a business needs it. And with the many different ways to outsource, such as contracted roles, the cost of outsourcing fits into what a business needs.
- Relieves stress
- Outsourcing is an easy way to find talent in areas outside of a business owner’s expertise, such as finances or website development, so that business owners can focus on running their business. Outsourcing removes the need for business owners to specialize in specific talents and hands the work to someone else who is more advanced in a certain field.
If you are looking for a flexible and cost-friendly way to find specialized talent, outsourcing can be a good option for your small business.
Pros of Hiring
On the other hand, hiring employees is a great way to build a growing business long-term and make everyday business operations more efficient. Hiring employees can be beneficial if you are looking to build areas of customer service or if you discover that your team would benefit from the addition of someone with new skills. Some benefits of hiring a team are:
- Creates a foundation and promotes growth
- It is important to have a team that works for the business to keep it growing and running. Hiring employees builds a small business and grows its size to boost efficiency and keep up with growing demand. Hiring employees can also help the growth of social relations by creating a team that cares about the business and its products and services.
- More control and better communication
- Hiring employees allows a business owner to have more control over those working for them and allows for better communication because of the daily interaction employees have with the business. Managers and owners have more oversight on daily operations with hired employees, which also makes communication easier by having direct and immediate contact with employees.
- Builds culture and boosts morale
- Hiring employees builds the culture of a growing business by having people who understand the business and its mission and can portray it through customer interaction. Businesses train employees in their mission to create an atmosphere that embodies core values. Hiring and training new employees boosts morale by bringing in a new energy that has a fresh understanding of the business’s mission and its values.
If you are looking to strengthen a business’s daily operations, have more involvement and control over those working for you, and deepen the business’s culture, hiring staff may be a good move for your business.
Cons of Outsourcing
While outsourcing and hiring have intriguing benefits, it is important to weigh their disadvantages while choosing what is the best move for your business. Outsourcing’s flexibility and cost-reducing nature can make it separate and independent from a small business as they work with other clients. Some disadvantages of outsourcing are:
- Lack understanding of your business
- Although outsourcing can be an efficient way to get more work done, different service providers may not have the best understanding of your business and its culture. The lack of understanding can affect the overall product the outsourced party gives a small business.
- Communication difficulties
- It may be hard to communicate with contractors or vendors due to communication methods and external factors such as time zones. Usually a business owner’s form of contact to other service providers is digitally, where information can get lost in communication. Outsourcing to service providers in different time zones can also impact communication abilities and delay the completion of a project.
- Creates dependency
- Outsourcing for a job can cause a business to be dependent on the contractor’s completion of a project or task or potentially become dependent on a business provider for future tasks. Dependency can weaken a small business because it can delay a business’s timeline when a project is not finished or can cause a growing business to lack skills it needs.
Cons of Hiring
Hiring the right candidate is important to establishing and growing a small business. It is important to hire employees that fit your business’s needs while carrying its culture, which can be a more tedious task. Some disadvantages of hiring are:
- More expensive
- Hiring employees tends to be more costly than outsourcing due to the cost of factors such as advertising for a position, training employees, and benefits.
- Time consuming
- The hiring process itself can be more time-consuming than outsourcing because of the interview process and training. Rounds of interviews can take away from a business’s valuable work time. Training employees in the necessary skillset can also be a tedious process that takes away from the business’s productivity.
- Limited talent pool
- Hiring employees can limit a business owner’s access to talent because of geographical limits and different recruitment websites. The selection of accessible talent shrinks when hiring in-person. And depending on where an employer posts a job opening, the talent pool can shrink further because some people may not have access to the listing.
Fractional Work
Other methods of hiring can reduce the cost and time of hiring and training employees, such as fractional work. Fractional work involves hiring a professional for their existing skills on a part-time or project-specific basis, which reduces the cost and time of hiring while expanding the accessible talent pool. WG Business Enterprises offers fractional services, such as fractional COO services, to help with strategy and project management so your business can thrive. To learn more about how business consultants and fractional COOs can grow and optimize your business, take a look at our post “How Business Consultants Can Help Your Business Thrive.”
Which is better?
Choosing whether to outsource or hire new employees depends on the needs of your business. If your goal is to supply more long-term help for your business, then hiring may be the route for you. If you are seeking to bolster a segment of your business or looking for someone to take a specialized task off of your plate, then outsourcing may be the way to go.
How to Decide what Your Business Needs
In order to decide whether hiring employees or outsourcing is the best move for your business, consider:
- The type of roll
- What kind of role are you trying to fill? Is the role associated with everyday operations, or is the role something that is behind the scenes or requires a specific skill set?
- The duration of time for a role
- Is the role that you are trying to fill a recurring need or something that is needed daily, or is the role a more time-sensitive need for a shorter period of time?
- Finances
- How much are you willing to spend on hiring or outsourcing? Can your finances support hiring someone and the additional costs that come with it, Or would outsourcing for a role better suit your financial situation?
- Doing research
- There are many ways to fill a position, so researching the options can help you gain more knowledge on whether to hire or outsource for a position. You can research different methods to fill your open position and discover what has worked best for other business owners who have been in a similar position.
Frequently Asked Questions
What roles are best to outsource?
- Outsourcing is typically best for short-term, limited projects that require specialized expertise. Roles such as design, marketing, IT, and bookkeeping are all positions that are great to outsource because they require specialized knowledge.
What roles are best to hire?
- Hiring is best when you are looking to build your business and want long-term support. Hire when you want to build culture and increase the efficiency of your daily operations. Roles related to daily operations, sales, and customer support are great to hire for because they need people who are knowledgeable about your business and consistent with how they take care of it.
How do I know if I can hire an employee?
- Hiring an employee is essential to having your business grow. When looking to hire, make sure your finances can support hiring a part-time or full-time employee. It is also important to look at the growth of your business so determine if your perceived cash flow can support the salary or hourly wage you proposed.
Is outsourcing less expensive than hiring?
- Outsourcing is typically less expensive than hiring. Typically a set rate is established with the team you are outsourcing to. Outsourcing also allows a small business to skip past the hiring and onboarding process and negates the need for the business to pay for employee benefits. Outsourcing is a quick way to get the experienced help your small business needs at a fraction of the cost of hiring an employee.
What is fractional work?
- Fractional work is when you hire an experienced professional on a part-time basis. Fractional work is useful for small businesses looking for advice and guidance to make their business grow. A fractional employee usually takes on a high-level position in management or leadership roles that can easily integrate a fractional employee into the business.
What roles are best to hire fractional work?
- Fractional work is a good option when you are looking to strengthen leadership and gain advice or guidance on your business. Roles such as fCOO, fractional chief of staff (FCoS), or a fractional project manager (FPM) are a great way to use fractional work because they require a high level of experience and expertise.
Still deciding outsourcing or hiring is right for you?
If you would like assistance or professional advice on whether your small business would benefit the most from outsourcing or hiring, WG Business Enterprises is here to help! Whitney will work with you to help decide if outsourcing or hiring best suits the needs of your business. Schedule a free consultation with WG Business Enterprises today and discover whether outsourcing or hiring is the right path for you.
Serving West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, and clients across the U.S.A
Free Business Resources & E-Books
Free Guide to SMART Goals for Businesses
Free Guide to Optimizing Your Business
Free Guide to a Hassle-Free Office Move
Connect with Us on Social Media
